A contest played at the end of some of the podcasts in which Mike Mitchell is pitted against a guest in a taste test to determine what mystery liquid has been given to them by Nick Wiger.
|Episode||Release date||Item||Mike Mitchell's guess||Guest's guess|
|Taco Bell with Jack Allison||May 25, 2015||Sprite LeBron's Mi||Cactus Cooler||Lemon Lime Jarritos|
|Outback Steakhouse with Jon Gabrus||June 4th, 2015||Arizona Watermelon Fruit Juice Cocktail||Strawberry Kiwi Arizona Iced Tea||Strawberry Kiwi Lemondade|
|Domino's with Matt Kowalick||July 16th, 2015||Mexican Coke||Coca-Cola||Off Brand Coca-Cola|
|Buffalo Wild Wings with Matt Selman||September 18th, 2015||Squirt||Squirt||Strange korean soda in a dark blue can|
|Fuddruckers with Ryan Perez||November 11th, 2015||Vita-Coco Coconut Water||Pineapple Coconut Water||Vita-Coco Coconut Water|
|Krispy Kreme with Matt Besser||January 28th, 2015||Clamato||Original V8||Diet V8|
|Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen with Lesley Arfin||May 26th, 2015||Strawberry Banana Body Armor Sports Drink||Kiwi Strawberry Snapple||Country Time Strawberry Banana Medley|
Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.