In this segment, the Doughboys try a food from a chain restaurant that had been purchased the day before. The purpose is to judge how well the food holds up after spending the night in the fridge. The theme song for this segment is from the HBO television show The Leftovers.
The rating scale is to either leave it behind on Earth (bad) or let it ascend to heaven (good).
| # | episode | food | majority result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 24 | Rockdoughberfest: Hard Rock Cafe with Scott Gardiner | Carl's Jr./Hardee's
Western Bacon Cheeseburger |
leave it behind |
| 42 | Tournament of Chompions: Steak ‘n Shake v. 6-seed | Subway Meatball Marinara | ascend to heaven |
| 80 | Hooters with Kulap Vilaysack | 7-Eleven Fresh To Go Pizza | leave it behind |
| 85 | Tony Roma's with Bug Mane | KFC Nashville Hot Chicken Wings
Cole Slaw |
ascend to heaven |
| 119 | KFC with Paul F. Tompkins | McDonald's Big Mac | ascend to heaven |
| 129 | Wienerschnitzel with Rob Huebel | Del Taco 1/2 pound
Bean and Cheese Burrito |
leave it behind |
| 151 | Farmer Boys with Nick Rutherford | Burger King Chicken Fries | leave it behind |
| 152 | Olive Garden 2 with Joel Kim Booster | Olive Garden Spaghetti with Meat Sauce | ascend to heaven |
| 259 | Whole Foods with Fran Gillespie | 7-11 Big Bite Hot Dog | leave it behind |
| 259 | Whole Foods with Fran Gillespie | 7-11 Go-Go Taquitos | leave it behind |