A Single Item Must Be Banished 🚫[]
In A Single Item Must Be Banished, a family of food items (or just any items) are presented and one must be banished forever.
| # | Episode | theme |
|---|---|---|
| 277 | Boston Market 2 with Dewayne Perkins | Thanksgiving dinner |
| 320 | Insomnia Cookies with Mary Sohn | Halloween things |
| 333 | Thighstop with Jon Gabrus | Chicken Scratch |
| 369 | Fazoli's with Mitra Jouhari | Italian cuisine |
| 380 | SushiStop with Alie Ward | Sushi |
| 401 | Jollibee 2 with John Early and Claudia O'Doherty | State Fair |
| 411 | Howlin' Rays with Kumail Nanjiani | Brands |
| 440 | Oakberry with Johnny TV and Taya Valkyrie | Beverages |
| 453 | Oops! All Segments! 2! | Cookouts |
| 456 | bb.q chicken with Tansu Philip | Boba |
Can I Take Your Order?[]
In Can I Take Your Order?, Nick gives Mitch and the guest the menu for a restaurant and then a number of restrictions from which they must choose their order. It is yet unclear how a winner is declared, or if it is indeed a competition at all.
| # | Episode | Restaurant | Restrictions | result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 276 | Paris Baguette with Lesley Tsina | Olive Garden | $25 (includes tax and tip)
must get a drink no pasta |
both failed |
| 282 | Panera Bread 2 with Monica Ruiz and Chris O'Malley | KFC | $10 (includes tax)
must be vegetarian |
Mitch spent too much
Monica & Chris win! |
| 288 | Papa John's 2 with Raiza Licea | Cheesecake Factory | brunch
no dairy |
Raiza won! |
Chain Storming[]
Chain Storming is a game in which Wiger spins a globe using an app on his phone, so it randomly stops on a country. They then create a chain restaurant based on that country. Wiger admits that it was not particularly thought out as a game, and they never do it again after its one appearance in episode 5.
| # | Episode | Country Chosen |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | Long John Silver's with Mary Holland | Malta |
Concessional[]
In Concessional, the Doughboys reveal some deep dark food-related secrets.
| # | Episode | Person | Secret |
|---|---|---|---|
| 174 | Octdoughberblessed: In-N-Out | Nick Wiger | like macaroni salad over potato salad |
| 174 | Octdoughberblessed: In-N-Out | Mike Mitchell | drinks leftover salad dressing |
| 174 | Octdoughberblessed: In-N-Out | Mike Mitchell | likes ketchup on scrambled eggs |
| 174 | Octdoughberblessed: In-N-Out | Mike Mitchell | recently spent $18.45 at Taco Bell
and ate it all himself |
| 174 | Octdoughberblessed: In-N-Out | Scott Aukerman | dips pizza in the paper plate grease puddles |
| 286 | Panda Express 3 with Oscar Montoya | Nick Wiger | put horseradish mustard on a salad |
| 286 | Panda Express 3 with Oscar Montoya | Mike Mitchell | ate a whole box of Cheez-Its |
| 286 | Panda Express 3 with Oscar Montoya | Mike Mitchell | lied to his Mum about getting Taco Bell |
| 286 | Panda Express 3 with Oscar Montoya | Oscar Montoya | puts deli meat in his microwave ramen |
Eatin' 9 to 5[]
In this segment, Mitch and the guest are office managers tasked with stocking their office kitchens from a list of items. Emma decides which office she would want to work at.
| # | episode | winner | Mitch's record |
|---|---|---|---|
| 361 | Nothing Bundt Cakes | Becky Feldman | 0 - 1 |
| 457 | Broccoli | Lindsay Katai & Kelly Nugent | 0 - 2 |
Hot Dog Creation[]
In this segment, the Doughboys each decided how to build the best hot dog with a limit of five toppings.
| guest / host | toppings |
|---|---|
| Nick Wiger | mustard
chili cheese raw onions relish |
| Mike Mitchell | ketchup
mustard relish onion spaghetti and marinara sauce |
| Betsy Sodaro | crispy onions
diced tomatos Ranch dressing jalapenos cheese |
Meal or No Meal[]
Meal or No Meal is a Doughboys version of Deal or No Deal, where one box has a hidden food item grand prize and there are five boxes with lesser prizes. Mitch and guest can pick a box and decide if they should keep it or keep trying for a better prize. The Dranker also appears to offer substitutions.
| # | Episode | theme | available prizes | offers | final winning prize |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 253 | Marie Callender's Meals with Cat Solen | chicken | Wendy's Spicy Chicken Sandwich
Subway 12" Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki sub Popeye's 3-piece Chicken Combo White Castle Chicken Ring Yoshinoya Chicken Teriyaki Bowl KFC Famous Bowl |
McDonald's 4-piece Chicken McNuggets
McDonald's 6-piece Chicken McNuggets McDonald's 10-piece Chicken McNuggets |
KFC Famous Bowl |
My Snackrifice[]
In My Snackrifice, the Doughboys have 3 categories of snacks and 3 options from within the category. They then decide which of these will be snackfriced for an entire year.
| # | Episode | category |
|---|---|---|
| 283 | Jersey Mike's 2 with Jon Daly | Peanut-Based Candy Bars
Coca-Cola Varietals Doritos Flavors |
Side of Guys[]
Side of Guys is a segment in which the Doughboys try two side orders from a restaurant and decide which is better.
The segment did not last and they only seem to have done it the one time.
| # | Episode | Restaurant | Choices | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12 | Chick-fil-A with Betsy Sodaro | Taco Bell | Cinnamon Twists
Cap'n Crunch Delights |
Cinnamon Twists |
The Slice Is Right[]
In the Slice is Right, the Doughboys work to develop a "dream pizza" by taking turns adding or removing toppings.
| # | episode | pizza |
|---|---|---|
| 57 | Hokkaido Ramen Santouka with Jeff Kenji Sloniker | Chicago-style cornmeal crust fresh mozzarella |
Unsatisfied Yelper[]
In this segment, Nick finds some 1 star reviews on Yelp and read them out loud.
| # | Episode | restaurant | city |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Chili’s with Eva Anderson | Chili's | Scottsdale, AZ |
| 2 | Taco Bell with Jack Allison | Taco Bell | San Diego, CA |
| 3 | IHOP with Alison Agosti | IHOP | Manhattan, NY |
| 4 | Outback Steakhouse with Jon Gabrus | Outback Steakhouse | Cumming, GA |
| 18 | Steak 'n Shake with Evan Susser | Steak 'n Shake | Santa Monica, CA |
| DD14 | Unsatisfied Yelpers with Erin Whitehead | Chuck E. Cheese's | Garland, TX |
| DD14 | Unsatisfied Yelpers with Erin Whitehead | Hooter's | Orlando airport |
| DD14 | Unsatisfied Yelpers with Erin Whitehead | Buca di Beppo | Las Vegas Strip |
| DD14 | Unsatisfied Yelpers with Erin Whitehead | Carrow's | Cerritos, CA |
| DD14 | Unsatisfied Yelpers with Erin Whitehead | Taco Bell | Quincy, MA |
| DD14 | Unsatisfied Yelpers with Erin Whitehead | Del Taco | Lakewood, CA |
| 200 | Chili's Too with Eva Anderson | Chili's Too | Las Vegas, NV |
| 300 | Guy Fieri's Flavortown Kitchen with Eva Anderson | Guy Fieri's Kitchen | Burbank, CA |
| 400 | Good Humor with Evan Susser | Chili's | Inglewood, CA |