Breaking Chews is a segment where the Doughboys try a newly-created food item and they rate it. The name Breaking Chews did not begin until episode 171, but there were a number of similar food tastings prior to that.
| # | Episode | Restaurant | Food | Rating |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| DD9 | Wendy Wexler with Evan Susser | Wendy's | Fresh Mozzarella Chicken Sandwich | 1.5 haba badoos |
| DD11 | Mama Mitchell with Corinne Mitchell | Taco Bell | Naked Chicken Chips | 1.5 triforces |
| DD16 | Zingin' and Jinglin' with Michael Cassady | KFC | KFC Zinger | Flinger |
| DD22 | Songs of Summer with Jessica McKenna | Wendy's | Bacon Queso Burger | - |
| DD22 | Songs of Summer with Jessica McKenna | Wendy's | Bacon Queso Chicken Sandwich | - |
| DD22 | Songs of Summer with Jessica McKenna | Wendy's | Bacon Queso Fries | - |
| DD37 | Naked Egg Odyssey with Heather Anne Campbell | Taco Bell | Naked Egg Taco | - |
| DD40 | Biggie Feedbag 4 with Yusong Liu | Burger King | Farmhouse King | 3.5 Blue Suede Shoes |
| DD | My Dinner with Wiger | Taco Bell | Nacho Fries | Sidegreat |
| DD | Secret Menu with Justin Lee | Jack in the Box | Cholula Buttery Jack | Drop |
| DD | Secret Menu with Justin Lee | Jack in the Box | Cholula Fries | Pop |
| DD | Big & Tall with Ross Kimball | Burger King | Sourdough King | Burger Prince |
| DD | Big & Tall with Ross Kimball | Burger King | Spicy Chicken Sandwich | Burger Prince |
| DD | Greek Bats with Julie Brister | Arby's | Traditional Greek Gyro | 4 Greek Bats |
| DD | Greek Bats with Julie Brister | Arby's | Roast Beef Gyro | 2.5 Greek Bats |
| DD | Greek Bats with Julie Brister | Arby's | Gyro Loaded Curly Fries | 2.46 Greek Bats |
| DD | Ba Da Ba Ba Ba with Jennie Pierson | McDonald's | Fresh Beef Quarter Pounder | Ba Da Ba Ba B |
| DD | Lakewood, California with Matt Apodaca | Dunkin' Donuts | Donut Fries | 4.83 Donut Fries |
| 171 | Outback Steakhouse 2 with Leann Bowen | Carl's Jr. / Hardee's | Fruit Loops Mini Donuts | Good Chews |
| DD | Irish Whiskey and American McRibs with Erin McGathy | McDonald's | McRib | 3.75 clovers |
| DD | Blue Velvet & Chew Year's Playlist with Jen Zaborowski | Cold Stone Creamery | Blue Velvet Brownie Creation | Atlanta |
| DD | Bacon Maple Gremlins with Nicole Byer | Wendy's | Bacon Maple Chicken Sandwich | don't give to a mogwai |
| DD | Little Caesar, Big Game with Ryan Meharry | Little Caesar's | Pretzel Crust Pizza | touchdown
with 2-pt. conversion |
| 192 | Native Foods with Tawny Newsome and Alex Kilner | McDonald's | Cheesy Bacon Fries | good but unnecessary |
| 194 | Poquito Más vs. Taco Bell with Mike Hanford | Starbucks | Iced Cinnamon Cloud Macchiato | Stank |
| DD | Game of P'Zones with Griffin Newman | Pizza Hut | P'Zone | 3.56 Death Sticks |
| DD | Mitchell-adas with Agata Monica and Anastasia Vigo | Burger King | Angry Whopper | 3.56 Shaq Shoes |
| DD | Mitchell-adas with Agata Monica and Anastasia Vigo | Burger King | Spicy Chicken Nuggets | 2.67 Shaq Shoes |
| DD | Beyond Chicago with Fran Gillespie | Carl's Jr. / Hardee's | Beyond Famous Star | 3.67 Agents |
| DD | From Sea to Shining McD with Jack Allison | McDonald's | Stroopwaffel McFlurry | - |
| DD | From Sea to Shining McD with Jack Allison | McDonald's | Cheesy Bacon Fries | - |
| DD | From Sea to Shining McD with Jack Allison | McDonald's | Tomato Mozzarella Chicken Sandwich | - |
| DD | From Sea to Shining McD with Jack Allison | McDonald's | Grand McExtreme Bacon Burger | - |
| DD | Garfield's Thanksgiving with Paul Rust | 7-Eleven | Merry Mash-up Mtn Dew Slurpee | 2.17 Turkey Feathers |
| DD | Quiznos Quiz Show with Mark Rennie | Quiznos | Lobster & Seafood Salad Sub | 0 Quiz Show Points |
| DD | Quiznos Quiz Show with Mark Rennie | Quiznos | Chipotle Steak & Cheddar Sub | 1.51 Quiz Show Points |
| DD | Quiznos Quiz Show with Mark Rennie | Quiznos | Turkey Bacon Guacamole Sub | 2.46 Quiz Show Points |
| 213 | Shaquille's with Josh Weiner | Papa John's | BBQ Chicken & Bacon Pizza | Waq |
| 217 | Burger King 3 with Haley Mancini | Krispy Kreme | Reese's Original Filled Donut | Brian Williams |
| 218 | Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen 2 with Andrew Ti | Popeyes | Chicken Sandwich | 4.67 forks |
| 221 | Marie Callender's with Scott Aukerman | 7-Eleven | Grape/Strawberry Nerds Slurpee | Drank |
| DD | The Twisted World of Pretzels | Burger King | Pretzel Bacon King | 4.13 Warm, Soft Pretzels |
| DD | Double Stacked Dano | Taco Bell | Double Stacked Taco - Nacho Crunch | - |
| DD | Double Stacked Dano | Taco Bell | Double Stacked Taco - Chipotle Cheddar | - |
| DD | Double Stacked Dano | Taco Bell | Double Stacked Taco - Reaper Ranch | - |
| DD | Buff Fries and Tiny Tacos with Matty Smith | Jack in the Box | Tiny Tacos | - |
| DD | Buff Fries and Tiny Tacos with Matty Smith | Jack in the Box | Loaded Tiny Tacos | - |
| DD | Buff Fries and Tiny Tacos with Matty Smith | Taco Bell | Buffalo Chicken Nacho Fries | - |
| DD | Buff Fries and Tiny Tacos with Matty Smith | Taco Bell | Buffalo Chicken Nacho Fries Burrito | - |
| 242 | McDonald's Round of 32 (Part 2) with Paul F. Tompkins | Carl's Jr. / Hardee's | The BFC | feed to The Blob |
| 248 | Pizza Hut 2 with Jen D'Angelo | Pizza Hut | The Big Dipper | - |
| DD | Mount Slushmore with Santina Muha | Taco Bell | Pineapple Whip Freeze | - |
| DD | Mount Slushmore with Santina Muha | Taco Bell | Pineapple Freeze | - |
| DD | Puppa Shaq's with Albert Corado | Papa John's | Shaq-a-Roni | 1.67 Guys Thrown Over The Roof |
| DD | The Band of Tomorrow with Caroline Anderson | McDonald's | The BTS Meal | 6 BTS Members (out of 7) |
| 435 | Subway 4 with Andre Hyland | Subway | Subway Sidekicks | - |